'Influencer fatigue' is real and young people are getting tired of it

Although the spectacle of influencers flaunting their affluence has long been a staple of social media, there are signs that audiences are growing tired of it. Experts say “influencer fatigue” is wearing on young people who crave authenticity as inflation rises and achieving a stable livelihood becomes increasingly difficult.

According to data from a YPulse study shared with Yahoo News, 45% of people between the ages of 13 and 22 say influencers just don’t have the same power that they used to. About 53% said they were more likely to trust recommendations from regular people online whom they don’t know rather than creators with large followings.

Influencer marketing once offered an alternative to typical celebrity marketing. Celebrities appeal to us as salespeople because of the psychological phenomenon known as the halo effect. If someone is talented or beautiful, we assume they are highly qualified in other ways as well, which boosts sales. Influencers, who are powerful but not conventionally famous, offered a more relatable and accessible alternative. They’re far enough removed from celebrities that we can relate to them — until we can’t.

iAvicenna,
@iAvicenna@lemmy.world avatar

dont worry new young people are growing up to watch this shit

unreasonabro,

i was tired of it the first time i heard of it

ObsidianZed,

Sorry if I’m unable to muster up any sympathy.

Also the phrase ‘getting tired of fatigue’ tickles me.

Strawberry,

did you read past the headline? it wasn’t about the influencers feeling fatigued

Paddzr,

Right, I thought it was a comment about how young people brought it onto themselves… This whole concept where they enabled influencers and now it’s on them.

cryostars,

Right, but are we supposed to muster up sympathy for people who follow influencers getting fatigued from following influencers? Really not trying to be snarky just curious

KeenFlame,

You can get fatigue from things you choose

It’s just a technical term for bored

Your synapses are saturated

It’s a very useless observation that this also has a tipping point like every other trend in history

Fedizen,

This is a bad sign for facebook

Strawberry,

are there influencers left on Facebook?

Paddzr,

Yes, strangely there’s even a gaming scene on fb too. It’s a big fucking world, not being first or second still means you could be pulling millions of people.

davemeech,

Probably an old man yelling at cloud sentiment, but I hated them from the very beginning.

Cosmicomical,

Influencer is a bad name, but I see them as bottom-up content creator, instead of the top-down conventional media. In this sense it’s more democratic approach and there is a wider choice and plurality of voices. But mainstream media is now enrolling them, for instance Reach Plc (who owns the Mirror and the Daily Express) fired a bunch of journalists and hired influencers. So you know, now you’re going to get the worst of two worlds.

nifty, (edited )
@nifty@lemmy.world avatar

I am not an old man, and I felt the same. I left Facebook in 2008, don’t have insta, TikTok, or tweet. I also left Reddit in 2014ish.

I only use HN (on and off to comment on articles), and recently started Lemmy. Will I stay? Idk. Some international acquaintances and friends use WhatsApp, but I’ve mainly quit it.

Potatos_are_not_friends,

I’m definitely an old man. And i remember when YouTube influencers started being a thing.

To this day, I have no idea what the hell a Mr Beast is or any of these famous YouTubers are. And most of them either fade away or get propped up by some bad news.

AgentGrimstone,

I never trusted what any influencer was selling. An ad disguised as a reddit post was way more effective on me.

octopus_ink,

Well us old people were already tired of them when they first showed up. shakes cane

AngryCommieKender,

I distinctly remember a show called Lifestyles of The Rich and Famous, though I couldn’t tell you what celebs were featured. Then MTV had Cribs in the '90s. Influencers are basically just the modern version of those shows, aren’t they?

octopus_ink,

Everyone keeps naming things that were always tiresome worship of excessive consumption and wealth. A good many of us were tired of them then, too.

CarbonatedPastaSauce,

Good old Robin Leach. I remember watching that show as a kid and feeling vaguely creeped out by him.

Dnn,

I thought that was the whole joke here.

octopus_ink,

I may very well have been too earnest in my response. :)

Duamerthrax,

Influences back then were just called Celebrity Endorsements. Or did you think Robert Rockwell wasn’t getting paid?

octopus_ink,

Bold of you to assume we weren’t tired of those, too.

gnomesaiyan,
@gnomesaiyan@lemmy.world avatar

Social media = slave mentality

JasonDJ,

Said on lemmy, the socialist media.

nifty,
@nifty@lemmy.world avatar

Internet forums were never social media. Link aggregators are a substitute for niche Internet forums.

Duamerthrax,

Can you name a single Lemmy power user who’s shilling something? the biggest users I can think of on .world are just posting Star Trek memes.

girl,

that isnt a requirement for something to be social media. lemmy is definitely social media, it’s better than most but still qualifies

Duamerthrax,

Different people have very different ideas of what social media is. No one really thinks of the old bulletin boards as social media, but if Lemmy is social media so are they. Some people only consider effective platforms for advertisement as real social media. For me, it requires some form of algorithm dumping shit down your throat or people over sharing.

girl,

I understand the connotation, most people only consider things like youtube, tiktok, and facebook social media. but there is an actual definition for social media and even the old chat boards fit that definition

JasonDJ, (edited )

Shills aren’t a requirement for social media.

Also it was kind of a joke. Lemmy is a social media, but it also socialist by the definition of the word. The joke enhanced by the fact that most the instances I’ve seen lean hard to the left.

a political and economic theory of social organization which that the means of production, distribution, and exchange should be owned or regulated by the community as a whole.

I suppose you could say the same about most the fediverse.

But give it time. Lemmy isn’t popular enough yet, but eventually there will be plenty of “users” exploiting the algorithms for financial or political gain. Lemmy hasn’t reached the critical mass necessary for that to be worthwhile.

FiniteBanjo,

That’s because the algorithm has grown recursive and shoves the same mainstream shit down everybody’s throat on repeat. Cake is cool but imagine never being allowed to eat anything other than cake.

theherk,

Death it is then I guess.

faceula,

No no no, you said cake first.

AngryCommieKender,

Death by cake?

devils_advocate,

We’re all out of cake.

fine_sandy_bottom,

Yeah but imagine admiring someone that needs a team of people to make it look like they made a cake.

TheControlled,

Oh please cow-fucking-god let this be true

TK420,

What a beautiful string of words

Notyou,

Is it a cow god that fucks or is it a god that fucks cows?

catloaf,

I assumed they were referring to Zeus.

TheControlled, (edited )

Ding ding ding

Edit: I don’t get it. Why does someone downvote me affirming someone’s assumption about what I said. Why are people like this?

TK420,

I like a god fucking cow image best

Mastengwe,

This is great news. It’s about time those idiots lost their audience.

tacosanonymous,

So the kids need a more realistic representation of adulthood?

My time as a homeowner who barely scrapes by is here.

isthingoneventhis,

We’ll go full circle back to the days of yore when home improvement HGTV wasn’t also bundled with an irl soap opera.

minibyte,

This old house.

Mongostein,

New Yankee Workshop, bro!

whotookkarl,
@whotookkarl@lemmy.world avatar

Or go full Running Man with it, win a million dollars if you can tape and paint a living room with a homicidal American gladiator chasing you around with a chainsaw

Powerpoint,

You already lost them by saying home owner. That’s not realistic

Zozano, (edited )

Realistic

Homeowner

Choose one.

Viking_Hippie,

If someone is talented or beautiful, we assume they are highly qualified in other ways as well

With apologies for sounding like a cranky old man 30 years too early: in my day, we didn’t call thinking that “the halo effect”. We called it being a gullible dumbass.

EatATaco, (edited )

We called it being a gullible dumbass.

The reality is that you’re almost certainly guilty of it. It’s human nature and to be so confident that everyone else is dumb and falls for it, and that it doesn’t bias your thoughts, is nothing but straight up arrogance.

I can almost guarantee that every person who upvoted your post, and you included, are probably more prone to it than average precisely because you think you are immune, so you don’t bother to consider checking your own bias.

Clent,

Oh soothsayer what does your wisdom say of those of us who saw them as sellouts? Or those of us that aren’t enamored by consumerism? Or both?

It would appear you are the one who has normalized these things in your mind as you have accepted them as inevitables.

TheControlled,

Unequivocally, what you said.

EatATaco, (edited )

It would appear you are the one who has normalized these things in your mind as you have accepted them as inevitables.

This is like saying that I’ve normalized car accidents because I tell you to wear your seatbelt, knowing full well they happen.

The people who think they are not prone to these types of biases are exactly like the dopes who don’t wear seatbelts. Either because they think they aren’t prone to accidents, or are simply just dumb.

Clent,

Marketing doesn’t work as well as marketers would like everyone to believe. It works better on people who believe it works.

EatATaco,

I’m not sure how one could possibly reason themselves into that position, so I guess I’ll just have to recognize that “you can’t reason a person out of a position they didn’t reason themselves into.”

Clent,

Your inability to determine how I have reasoned my way into something is about you not me.

Your dismissal of my ability to reason this and claim I didn’t reason myself into it, is a contradiction to the first half of your statement.

It would appear you are caught up by your own limitations. Your choice to project these limitations on others indicates you are incapable of recognizing others have not only different perspective but different life experiences.

EatATaco,

Instead of just throwing out a lot of empty insults, you could have just demonstrated I am wrong by explaining your reasoning. By not doing so, you just confirmed that I am right. Well done. Thank you.

Clent,

Am I did you give you my life story? You’ve asked no questions. Displayed no inquisitive nature from which to build a response.

You are the one throwing insults. I started with mocking tone and everything since has been placing a mirror to your insult attempts.

If you need an insult, I can easily provide one. You are a vapid know nothing.

EatATaco,

You were challenged, now twice, to actually show your reasoning. And you’ve chosen, now twice, to avoid providing it.

We both know why, it’s just a matter of whether you’re willing to admit it, or if you will just keep throwing out empty insults to deflect away from what we both know is the truth.

Clent,

You’ve got a knack for this self righteousness, consistently too.

You can’t even ask nicely. Good luck with that.

EatATaco,

Yes, it’s my fault you can’t support your position. Why didn’t I see that? Lol

Cosmicomical,

Being aware of psychological phenomena used in marketing doesn’t immunize you, I agree. But it definitely helps.You end up sounding paranoid to your friends, but you know those are real mechanisms that are used against you.

otp,

Even our fairy tales and popular media often have ugly villains and beautiful (or “pure”) heroes.

Olhonestjim,

Sure, we’re all guilty of it, but telling someone that their decision making process is adversely affected by the Halo Effect might not be quite so convincing as warning them that they’re being a gullible dumbass.

EatATaco, (edited )

If you tell someone only gullible people fall for it…well, I’m not gullible so obviously I don’t fall for it. However if you tell someone we are all flawed humans that fall for it, they are more likely to be like “hmm, when does it affect my decision making process?”

Although I’m under no false assumption that either is very effective. People mostly don’t want to admit that they are ever less than completely rational and objective.

Socsa,

What if I am genuinely a misanthrope who hates people?

EatATaco,

Unless you hate everyone equally, which is almost certainly not the case, then it probably is still true.

sigmaklimgrindset, (edited )

The “Halo Effect” has been a known psychological phenomenon since 1907 researched by uh…Wells and someone else who I can’t remember.

I don’t want to rain on your cranky old man parade, but unless you’re 100+ years old I don’t think it was ever just “being a gullible dumbass”, it’s very much a known societal bias that has been leveraged by the advertising industry. Don’t think you’re immune to it just because you think you’re “above it”.

Viking_Hippie,

I was trying to be humorous lol. I know that it’s a common bias, but just being aware of it and how it’s not based in reality is enough to not act on it.

I’m not 100+ years old (though it can feel like it some mornings), but people have been aware of the phenomenon and the insidious exploitation of it for a long while and

https://lemmy.world/pictrs/image/a58c93aa-f740-4716-a065-560f54bbbeba.jpeg

Olhonestjim,

You just made me imagine GI Joe warning kids about logical fallacies rather than just the dangers of swimming in front of the local dam.

Viking_Hippie,

You’re welcome 😁

vaultdweller013,

That souns like a solid JJ bit.

ctkatz,

what the fuck is an “influencer” anyway?

maybe it’s because I have always thought for myself, but when I hear influencer I think in my head “online attention w. hor. e. whose 15 minutes ended 15 hours ago”.

if kids are not paying attention to narcissistic craving it and thinking for themselves as a side benefit it can only be a good thing.

brygphilomena,

Say it. Say whore. You are allowed to.

Stop censoring yourself so other people can more easily appeal to advertisers. I fucking hate that so many people censor themselves so someone else can make more money.

BottleOfAlkahest, (edited )

Theyre on lemmy.ml and they likely can’t say it on their instance without it being autocensored. I also don’t agree with a lot of .ml stances but I don’t think they’re selling advertising space over there, has that changed recently?

Edit: I’m bad at spelling

otp,

Lmao…sounds like they should create an account on a different instance.

ryan213,
@ryan213@lemmy.ca avatar

I just follow them for bikini pics, man.

TheControlled,

Part of the solution, or part of the problem.

PriorityMotif,
@PriorityMotif@lemmy.world avatar

It doesn’t matter if they’re already paying for millions of fake subscribers and fake comments. There’s no secret sauce to this stuff. Just pay the shady account harvesting company in se Asia a few $k and you’ll get a lot of views and clicks.

  • All
  • Subscribed
  • Moderated
  • Favorites
  • news@lemmy.world
  • DreamBathrooms
  • ngwrru68w68
  • tester
  • magazineikmin
  • thenastyranch
  • rosin
  • khanakhh
  • InstantRegret
  • Youngstown
  • slotface
  • Durango
  • kavyap
  • mdbf
  • tacticalgear
  • JUstTest
  • osvaldo12
  • normalnudes
  • cubers
  • cisconetworking
  • everett
  • GTA5RPClips
  • ethstaker
  • Leos
  • provamag3
  • anitta
  • modclub
  • megavids
  • lostlight
  • All magazines