berkeleyblue, 30 days ago Not at all. You said being alone in a forest with a man is more dangerous than a bear, and I said that’s statistically nonsense. Just because I wrote more than 2 sentences, doesn’t make that a gish gallop. There are 2 premises: Bears are dangerous (I agree) A random man in a forest is more dangerous to a woman than that bear (I strongly disagree) I showed my numbers for that 1 argument and that’s it. I’m happy to be proven wrong, if you have anything more than “it just is”. I’m not defensive I find this comparison to be simply ridiculous.
Not at all. You said being alone in a forest with a man is more dangerous than a bear, and I said that’s statistically nonsense.
Just because I wrote more than 2 sentences, doesn’t make that a gish gallop.
There are 2 premises:
I showed my numbers for that 1 argument and that’s it. I’m happy to be proven wrong, if you have anything more than “it just is”.
I’m not defensive I find this comparison to be simply ridiculous.