optimisey,
@optimisey@seocommunity.social avatar

How would you diagnose this website's #seo

Chart shows impressions from Search Console data.

For best part of a year, Google did not like this site.

A year later it's recovering.

What did I change?

Absolutely. Nothing.

Literally, not one thing.

Was the content less "helpful" before? But is "helpful" now? When it's the same content...?

michael_martinez,
@michael_martinez@c.im avatar

@optimisey It could just be that other sites shot themselves in the foot.

It could also be that query patterns changed. SEO cannot force people to use certain queries.

And it could be that the site was accidentally punished by algorithmic bugs that have since been fixed.

There are a lot of reasons for why this happens - none of them having anything to do with SEO.

optimisey,
@optimisey@seocommunity.social avatar

@michael_martinez Yup.

Frustrating though, isn't it?

It reminds me of the old days, trying to get a phone signal and you'd stand in one spot, or wave your phone around, or stick your arm in the air or whatever and then SUDDENLY one bar of signal!

Only, you're not sure which of the things you did changed it... or whether it was something else entirely. 😄

Fizzle_Up,
@Fizzle_Up@seocommunity.social avatar

@optimisey @michael_martinez Honestly, I've seen this happen a few times too & can't fathom an explanation. One of the many mysteries in our field.

Other times, you're sure you've made way better improvements & elevated your content & technical above & beyond your competitors & things take a nosedive. Sometimes you just throw your hands up & have to start again.

It's rare, but frustrating when it happens. Damn anomalies!

heysannidhi,
@heysannidhi@c.im avatar

@Fizzle_Up @optimisey @michael_martinez
@simoncox
@geekonaut

All respondents: Interesting replies.

> What did I change?
> Absolutely. Nothing.
> Literally, not one thing.

  • Serious question: General reaction would be to tweak and see approach or to A/B test. I'm am curious to know as to what made you not optimize anything for over a year? Were you expecting it to be picked up automatically? What was your thought process?
simoncox,
@simoncox@seocommunity.social avatar

@heysannidhi @Fizzle_Up @optimisey @michael_martinez @geekonaut

Sometimes it is good to have a site that sits there without changes for a year or more. With some smaller businesses that is fine - they don't need to constantly optimise the site - frankly they will not be able to afford it. For #seo purposes these are great sites to have as a baseline. They should in theory wane over time but if locally focused, then often not.

michael_martinez,
@michael_martinez@c.im avatar

@simoncox @heysannidhi @Fizzle_Up @optimisey @geekonaut

For our affiliate portfolio, we may make some changes that we were thinking of making anyway, or we may continue to add new content without changing the basic strategy.

A few years ago some of our advertising-supported sites were suddenly outranked by a network of MFAs that took our articles and rewrote them. We decided to focus on other projects rather than fight that battle, as the other sites were using automation.

Having a portfolio of sites makes it easier to pivot to something else. And some of our sites are now doing about as well or better than after the competitors showed up - but they're all gone now.

simoncox,
@simoncox@seocommunity.social avatar

@optimisey
Is it a ski chalet website? - thinking it might be seasonal - probably way off the mark though!

optimisey,
@optimisey@seocommunity.social avatar

@simoncox Good question.

Meant to say, this is very much not a seasonal business, no.

simoncox,
@simoncox@seocommunity.social avatar

@optimisey
I'd say something changed even if you did not do it. That is either something on the site, server or CDN. If it's a WP site then it might have been hacked and something unpleasent added. I'm not sure a Google change could affect something so drastically and then come back, unless there was a manual penalty... and I am presuming that chart is for the whole site not a query or a page. SSL cert not renewed correctly?

optimisey,
@optimisey@seocommunity.social avatar

@simoncox Yup, whole site.

Nope, no hack, no domain renewal lapse or SSL ssliping (sorrynotsorry). No manual penalty either.

I realise I'm presenting this as a puzzle I have the answer to - but I genuinely don't.

Literally nothing has changed - bar the traffic tanking and then recovering.

simoncox,
@simoncox@seocommunity.social avatar

@optimisey
Well if that is fall out from the HCU then I can understand people tearing hair out!

  • All
  • Subscribed
  • Moderated
  • Favorites
  • SEO
  • DreamBathrooms
  • mdbf
  • ethstaker
  • magazineikmin
  • GTA5RPClips
  • rosin
  • thenastyranch
  • Youngstown
  • osvaldo12
  • slotface
  • khanakhh
  • kavyap
  • InstantRegret
  • Durango
  • megavids
  • everett
  • tester
  • cisconetworking
  • Leos
  • cubers
  • modclub
  • ngwrru68w68
  • tacticalgear
  • anitta
  • provamag3
  • normalnudes
  • JUstTest
  • lostlight
  • All magazines